Annabelle Doll Handler Dan Rivera Dies During Paranormal Tour—Police Dismiss Supernatural Link

• by Arlen Fitzpatrick
• 0 Comments

Unexpected Death Shocks Paranormal Community

Few names in the paranormal world carried the same intrigue as Dan Rivera, especially after he became the face most associated with the notorious Annabelle doll. On July 13, 2025, Rivera—just 54—was found unresponsive in a Gettysburg hotel room, sending shockwaves through fans, skeptics, and ghost hunters alike.

Rivera was in Pennsylvania as part of the 'Devils on the Run Tour', a joint event organized by the New England Society for Psychic Research (NESPR) and Ghostly Images of Gettysburg. The event aimed to blend local Civil War history with the chilling draw of paranormal artifacts. It drew out true believers and the curious by the dozens, all hoping for a brush with the supernatural.

What set this tour apart? The actual Raggedy Ann doll that inspired the terrifying Annabelle legend was on display—though, according to Sheriff’s deputies, the doll wasn’t even in the hotel when Rivera died. Rumors started the second the news broke: Was Annabelle involved? Had Rivera’s years of handling the supposed conduit for evil caught up with him in some sinister way?

No Evidence of Foul Play

The numbers came quickly: no weapons, no signs of forced entry, no reason to think foul play was a factor. Adams County Coroner Scott Pennewill clarified that, although Rivera’s cause of death remains unknown pending an autopsy, authorities have “found nothing unusual.” Translation: the drama was entirely in people’s imaginations this time.

Still, the timing made it hard for some fans to accept. Rivera, known for his role as the lead investigator with NESPR, was at the heart of the Annabelle myth, bolstered by blockbuster horror movies like 2013’s The Conjuring. Yet, officials were quick to point out that Rivera’s passing had no connection to the notorious doll or the supernatural stories swirling around it.

Fellow investigators and friends didn’t hesitate to praise Rivera’s commitment to the paranormal and his desire to educate others without sensationalizing the work. The NESPR’s Facebook page quickly became a virtual memorial, with posts focusing on his generosity and passion for making even skeptics curious about the unknown.

The Devils on the Run Tour itself had included fan-favorite stops like Gettysburg’s Haunted Orphanage, locations infused with ghost stories and tragic local lore. Attendees at these events often exchanged nervous laughter after interacting with the doll—always under Rivera’s watchful eye.

The Annabelle legend began with 1970s claims of the doll’s possession by a spirit and snowballed into something far bigger thanks to pop-culture. Rivera arguably played second only to Ed and Lorraine Warren in stoking Annabelle’s reputation—and dealt with plenty of pressure as a real-life handler of a horror icon.

While the cause of death is still up in the air, the police and coroner have been adamant: even with a history as strange as Annabelle’s in the background, there’s no reason to believe anything otherworldly happened to Dan Rivera. As his colleagues and fans try to make sense of his sudden loss, Rivera remains remembered not for sensationalism, but for his obsession with respectfully investigating the mysterious places between life and legend.